[ANSOL-geral] [Fwd: HD-DVD key fiasco is an example of 21st century digital revolt]

[João Miguel Neves]

Bom dia,

Um erro importante no artigo:

1) Não foi um "takedown notice" ao abrigo da DMCA - um takedown notice
(que em Portugal foi transformado numa providência cautelar) implica um
desrespeito pelo direito de autor. Não é o caso.

2) Eles estão a tentar eliminar conteúdo não por ser uma violação de
direito de autor a sua distribuição, mas por poder ser usado para
circumvenção de medidas de controlo de acesso. Desse ponto de vista, as
cartas são um normal "Cease and Desist".

Cumprimentos,
						João Miguel Neves

PS: Em Portugal estamos safos (na minha opinião de não advogado), mas
noutros países vai ser interessante ver os resultados: a distribuição do
número é realmente ilegal. Sim, a situação é completamente diferente da
DeCSS Gallery.

Qua, 2007-05-02 às 18:29 +0100, Carlos Patrão escreveu:
> anexo mensagem de e-mail (HD-DVD key fiasco is an example of 21st
> century digital revolt)
> > ------ Mensagem Reencaminhada ------
> > De: Fernando Fernandez <fernandez65  gmail.com>
> > Para: undisclosed-recipients : ;
> > Assunto: HD-DVD key fiasco is an example of 21st century digital
> > revolt
> > Data: Wed, 02 May 2007 18:05:12 +0100
> > 
> > 
> > HD-DVD key fiasco is an example of 21st century digital revolt
> > Posted May 1st 2007 4:30PM by Grant Robertson
> > Filed under: Internet, Security, News, P2P

> > 
> > It's the most circulated number of the week. Sixteen hexadecimal
> > digits that unlock the wonder of most currently released HD-DVD
> > titles from the surly clutches of the AACS revenue content
> > protection system. Sixteen digits that have been posted in so many
> > places -- and in many cases, removed only to be reposted -- that
> > they're hard to avoid. 
> > 
> > Cory Doctorow's class blog for his USC course, "Pwned: How everyone
> > on campus is a copyright criminal" was served a DMCA takedown notice
> > and, on the advice of counsel, removed the offending digits. They
> > were posted to Wikipedia, then removed and locked from reposting.
> > Then the diggstorm came. A slew of digg stories containing the
> > forbidden digits have been posted, made the front page and been
> > removed, only to start again. 
> > 
> > Witness the modern equivalent of the 95 thesis' Martin Luther nailed
> > to the door of Wittenburg church. We, digital citizens --commonly
> > referred to by the vulgar term of 'consumers' -- have had enough of
> > content lock-in. We've bought and re-bought entertainment media --
> > repackaged and regurgitated digital vomitus -- until we're blue in
> > the face. We've been told time and time again that DRM is for our
> > own protection, and we're finally and inconsolably fed up. 
> > 
> > As Joe Rogan's character on Newsradio once quite accurately quipped,
> > "Dude, you can't take something off the Internet.. that's like
> > trying to take pee out of a swimming pool." The content providers
> > have attempted to do exactly that, remove pee from the proverbial
> > swimming pool that is the Internet and, as we've witnessed so many
> > times before, they've failed miserably. 
> > 
> > The bottom line remains, we as consumers, want our content free (as
> > in Freedom) and if we don't get it, we'll take our content free (as
> > in beer).
> > 
> > 
> _______________________________________________
> Ansol-geral mailing list
> Ansol-geral  listas.ansol.org
> http://listas.ansol.org/mailman/listinfo/ansol-geral
-------------- próxima parte ----------
Um anexo que não estava em formato texto não está incluído...
Nome : não disponível
Tipo : application/pgp-signature
Tam  : 191 bytes
Descr: Esta =?ISO-8859-1?Q?é?	assinada digitalmente
Url  : http://listas.ansol.org/pipermail/ansol-geral/attachments/20070503/18cd3b1e/attachment-0001.pgp